Who is accountable
From the officers who run it up to the minister and the head of government. Names from the Government's official lists.
- Ministry of Home Affairs
- Home SecretaryShri Govind Mohan
- Minister of Home AffairsShri Amit Shah
- Prime MinisterShri Narendra Modi
File a grievance on CPGRAMS (Government of India)
As on: Ministers as on 25 Jul 2026; Secretaries as on 1 Oct 2026DoPT — Secretaries to the Government of India (as on 01.10.2026)Cabinet Secretariat — Council of Ministers with portfolios (as on 25.07.2026)
Community service as punishment for petty offences such as littering
India in Nutshell (starter topic)· 3 hours ago
No action reported yet.
Progress so far (0)
No progress reported yet.
Proposal: people who litter, spit or damage public property do supervised community service, such as cleaning, sanitation drives, or helping at public hospitals, instead of only paying a small fine.
Already in law
The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 added community service as a form of punishment (Section 4(f)) for certain petty offences. The open questions are how widely it should apply and how to implement it fairly.
Points to consider
- Dignity and safety. For example, nobody should be sent into sewers without protective equipment.
- Fair, consistent application regardless of wealth or influence.
- Who supervises, and how is completion verified?
Sources:
- LiveLaw explainer: livelaw.in/amp/lawschool/articles/commun…
- NLIU Law Review: nliulawreview.nliu.ac.in/community-service-under-the-b…
Results
no votesNo votes yet. Be the first.
Participants are self-selected; this is not a survey of all Indians.
For · Support
No arguments on this side yet.
Against · Oppose
No arguments on this side yet.